When you chomp into one of the piled-high Reuben or corned beef specials at Hershel’s, you’ll understand why locals refer to this place as “the best Jewish deli outside New York.” From its old-fashioned signage and counter seating to made-from-scratch menu items—including impossibly juicy, house-cured pastrami—every detail oozes authenticity. And it’s no wonder, considering that Hershel himself, a Polish native, was a chef at New York City’s legendary Katz’s Deli for more than 40 years. In 2000, with the help of close friend and business partner Andrew Wash, Hershel’s nephew, Stephen Safern, opened the deli in 2000 to honor his uncle’s legacy and Eastern European heritage. At Hershel’s East Side Deli, Safern and his team serve up a full assortment of Jewish deli classics, including matzo ball and chicken noodle soup, latkes, kugel, hot dogs, potato knishes, bagels with lox, hand-poured cheesecake, and, of course, hot deli sandwiches stuffed with homemade corned beef, pastrami, or brisket. Their food is made from scratch daily, the meat is carved to order, and the staff are happy to honor special requests—“just how Uncle Hirsh would have wanted it done.”

Hershel’s is pleased to now offer Tuckahoe Cheesecake with flavors that include Classic, Chocolate Chip, Raspberry Swirl, Cookies & Cream, Belgian Chocolate and more! Tuckahoe Cheesecake is a family-owned and operated small business in Tuckahoe, NJ, established in 1981. All products are made on the premises using high-quality ingredients. A Jersey Shore favorite, now available at Hershel’s East Side Deli!

Eateries Icon

Merchant Information

Mon - Sat: 8am-6pm
Sun: 9am-5pm

Year Opened: 2000

Map Location: B6

Payments Accepted: Cash, Credit Cards, RTM Gift Cards


Get In Touch